To make room for its new kid brother the Acura TSX, this TL starts a bit higher than the outgoing one. $33,670 buys a TL with either transmission; choose the manual and you also get a limited-slip differential, bigger stabilizer bars, Brembo front brakes, and somehow, a 93-pound weight reduction. The only option on all models is the $2,000 navigation system; $200 performance tires are also available on manual models. Everything else - heated leather power seats, driver memory, sunroof, dual-zone climate controls, stability control, six air bags, HID headlights, 3 months of XM radio, and that head-of-the-class stereo - is already in the box. And it probably doesn't hurt that the TL was named one of the Ten Vehicles That Will Best Hold Their [resale] Value by Kelley Blue Book.
Competition is hard to pin down simply because very few automakers choose to throw a front-drive family sedan into battle with more dedicated machinery. Going by price and brand name, Acura's TL goes up against such stalwarts as the BMW 3-series, Lexus IS, and many others - cars that essentially trade useful back-seat space for greater driving pleasure and rear-wheel-drive.
Judging by mechanical layout, the TL has exactly one competitor, the Toyota Camry-sourced Lexus ES330 (starting at $32,825, though with less standard fare). These two are more alike than different, but Acura went for performance while Lexus ran for the ultra-plush end of the spectrum, which should make this dichotomy a fairly easy decision after personal preferences come into play. To cite one example, TL fans would probably find 45 horsepower a lot to sacrifice.
Up through last year, Infiniti had a TL equivalent of its own, the Nissan Maxima-based I35. But this ended up being a temporary holdover until Infiniti released the G35, a far more advanced car whose rear-wheel-drive, multilink-suspended chassis gave it a strong shot of legitimacy and potential that was utterly lacking in the I35, while giving up nothing. Once the G hit the streets, the I was mercilessly killed.
Unfortunately, the G35 isn't such good news for the TL, either. A quick glance shows the G35 taking the trophy in space, price, 10 or 28 more horsepower, and that all-important rear-wheel-drive to put the power to better use. Acura might be able to use the "we may be stuck with front-drive, but we're roomier and faster and more reliable" against the Germans, but there's no hiding from the G35. With Infiniti's Acura-matching quality and Acura-matching luxury, it's hard to make an argument to pay more for the TL.
Finally, any analysis of the TL can't end without a mention of that Honda Accord EX V6. Knowing how similarly they drive (from the seat of my pants), extra front-wheel power, bigger wheels, a manual shiftgate for the automatic transmission, and DVD Audio does not equate to a $6,305 premium in my book. Honda quality is also too high to make Acura's longer warranty anything but a moot point. And on it goes.
|